One of the principal things that you gain from watch magazines, web journals and gatherers is that quartz watches are off breaking point. They need soul, they are modest or possibly degrade the watch and fundamentally can’t be paid attention to when you’re into gathering watches.

Whenever somebody asks what my calling is, I advise the person in question that I expound on watches. Mechanical watches. As this makes the clarification that I am just expounding on genuine watches excess. In any case, it is obviously not reality, there’s more to this than the development of a watch. Gerard expounded on his affection for G-Shocks various occasions, including in one of the new You Asked Us features . However, shouldn’t something be said about more costly watches that have a quartz development inside. Like the new Cartier Santos for instance, or a Grand Seiko with 9F movement.

Our question today comes from Mark from Germany.

Does It Make Sense To Spend So Much On A Quartz Watch?

Mark isn’t completely new to gathering watches, however the way that specific very good quality watch brands proceed (or begin to) offer watches with quartz developments befuddle him. Let’s view his letter (deciphered from German):

Dear Fratello team,

It is with extraordinary joy that I read your You Asked Us points on the magazine, it gives important bits of knowledge to gatherers like me. I’m not a specialist yet, but rather additionally not a beginner gatherer. In any case, when taking a gander at the Cartier oddity from this year at SIHH or one of your surveys of the Grand Seiko with quartz development, I am somewhat confounded. I was constantly encouraged that quartz developments are not to be paid attention to with regards to costly watches. However the completion appeared on the Grand Seiko quartz developments is something that can’t be overlooked. What is your opinion about extravagance watches with quartz developments? Does it get sense to go through such a lot of money flow on a watch with a quartz movement?



In request to respond to Mark’s question in the most ideal manner conceivable, let’s view a portion of the reasons why a quartz development can be interesting.


Just all things considered, I don’t think there’s anything amiss with a quartz watch. The way that a creator watch (Daniel Wellington, CK, Fossil, Diesel and so on) watch has a quartz development is something intelligent, as it has a lot to do with cost. Nonetheless, there are likewise watches with a mechanical development that I additionally don’t pay attention to very. So first of all, I would say that you need to pass judgment on the watch thusly, not just founded on the way that it has a quartz movement.

Some watches have quartz developments since they have usefulness that fundamentally requires one. The computerized watches from Breitling, Omega and Tissot come to mind obviously. As a proprietor of a Speedmaster X-33 myself, I can just underline how extraordinarily very much assembled this watch is, and that the quartz development offers usefulness intended for space travelers and pilots that can’t be finished with a mechanical watch. However, these experts need a solid watch that will actually want to take some genuine maltreatment. The equivalent applies to the Breitling Aerospace, B1, Emergency and the Exospace for example.


Some individuals incline toward truly slight watches. Also, despite the fact that brands like Bvlgari and Piaget for instance, offer extraordinarily slight watches with mechanical developments, these unquestionably come at a specific cost. At the point when Cartier presented their Santos-Dumont recently, we were entirely intrigued by its magnificence. Some portion of the magnificence was because of the elements of this watch. Simply 7mm thick, an ideal companion for somebody who cherishes a super slight dress watch. The steel model comes at a cost of $3900USD. The programmed rendition of the Santos in steel is practically 9mm and has a > $6000USD sticker price. At that point, likewise understand this isn’t your common quartz development. More about that later.


In all trustworthiness here, each assortment needs a battery worked watch. Maybe even with radio controlled activity, or GPS even. You need to have in any event one watch that can be the reference with regards to setting the entirety of your mechanical watches. I utilize my Casio G-Shock Multiband for that. Yet, basically a quartz watch isn’t an assurance that it doesn’t lose or acquire time. Modest quartz developments will undoubtedly have a higher deviation than the purported High Accuracy Quartz developments. Instances of those are obviously the Grand Seiko 9F, Breitling’s Super Quartz and Longines VHP (Very High Precision) quartz developments. The more costly quartz developments use thermo-compensation, for instance. The Grand Seiko 9F development checks for variety in temperatures up to 540 times each day, and consequently compensate for these progressions to guarantee high accuracy.

Talking about the 9F development from Grand Seiko, these additionally have a system set up that guarantees that the second’s hand stop precisely at the markers, with no vibration. Likewise, Grand Seiko just uses the most faultless quartz precious stones for their 9F developments. Much the same as jewels, there are contrasts in regards to the lucidity of these precious stones, influencing the exactness of the movement.

Although the creator of did a few tests on the precision of quartz developments and reasoned that even the less expensive developments had the option to keep time inside a second of the day, this may in any case amount to a couple of moments a month. The High Accuracy Quartz developments like the 9F can be pretty much as precise as a deviation of 10 seconds per year maximum.

If this is similarly as essential to you as the completion of any remaining pieces of a watch, and the expense isn’t, [luxury] brands like Grand Seiko, Longines, Breitling and Cartier for instance, offer the most awesome aspect both worlds.

Mechanical Versus Quartz

Or better said, mechanical versus high exactness quartz. Back in 2016, I commented on the Grand Seiko SBGV019G with 9F quartz development that I was glad that they set a presentation back on this model. Thusly, individuals can perceive how all around completed and tastefully satisfying their top of the line quartz development really is. Quite recently, we got the new Grand Seiko SBGN005 (GMT) with 9F86 development. This watch has a shut case back, which I find for this situation even somewhat of a bummer. It would show that quartz doesn’t equivalent cheap.

When it comes to excellence, we can’t circumvent the Oyster Quartz developments utilized by Rolex till around 2000. Gerard expounded on these OQ movements:

The Rolex Oysterquartz developments are among the most delightful quartz calibers at any point made. In addition to the fact that they have 11 bearing gems, yet the guideline is indeed done by a bed fork and wheel. The specialized plan of the 5035 and 5055 calibers unmistakably shows that Rolex planned this development to be as useful, and keep going as long, as their mechanical movements.

Still, notwithstanding the exertion that brands put into these quartz developments, regardless of whether they are stylishly engaging or simply very exact, it is unbelievably hard to emphatically impact the view of quartz developments that (genuine) gatherers have. The main inquiry we posed to Cartier when they showed us their Santos Dumont observe last January, was if there are plans to deliver it with a slender hand-twisted development as well.

Observing a mechanical development resembles a live symphony in amazing congruity though, for quartz, the music has been blended in the studio, giving maybe a more wonderful outcome. Having the option to tune in to the ensemble in a show lobby is a completely unexpected involvement with comparison to placing that CD with a similar music in your vehicle sound system. It isn’t just about the experience however, yet in addition about the craftsmanship expected to make it so perfect.

Even however a quartz development can be flawlessly completed, it is regularly the principle plate that there’s consistently the battery and some other vital parts present that ruin the view. There’s minimal that should be possible about that,  I presume. Eventually, it involves what you – as a watch devotee – find generally significant. I do feel that shamefulness is being done when individuals express that all quartz watches need soul. That may be material for the modest 100 USD quartz watch or the normal designer’s piece that we as a whole love to skip, yet it is similarly as relevant to mechanical watches that are gravely planned and built. The spirit of a watch isn’t in the development, it is in the exertion and craftsmanship that went into planning and making it.

Answering The Question

In the sections above I think I addressed the first question of Mark about how I feel towards quartz developments in extravagance watches. His principle question, Does it get sense to go through such a lot of money flow on a watch with a quartz movement?, is something that is more hard to reply. On the off chance that there’s a decision, let’s say two indistinguishable watches and one has a quartz development (be it a High Accuracy Quartz one with thermo-compensation and heavenly completing) and the other one has a pleasantly completed mechanical development, I would consistently go for the mechanical development. When the factors change, my answer may change as well.

As an outrageous model: let’s say a Grand Seiko with 9F development versus a $1000 USD watch with a mechanical development (be it Miyota or even a standard Sellita or ETA), I’d go for the Grand Seiko with quartz movement.

So in specific cases, indeed, it can bode well to spend a ton of cash on a watch with a quartz development. Be it for usefulness, stylish favorable circumstances (extremely meager at an adequate cost) or when precision is overly essential to you. I trust I have shown you, and Mark, that not all quartz developments are waste or ought to be overlooked by default.

You Asked Us

If you have an inquiry for us, round out the structure beneath and it may get included in a committed article.

[contact-structure 7 id=”75601″ title=”You Asked Us”]